
While there are concerns about the estimated visitor numbers and the annual income plus comparability of New England Rail Trail (NERT) plan by Armidale Regional Council (ARC) with other successful ones elsewhere that run through already established tourist destinations with facilities, our overriding concerns are as follows:
- Why should the ARC use a rail easement publicly owned by the NSW Government and remove existing rail infrastructure to build it?
- . Isn’t ARC’s design for the cycling/walking trail a selfish deciison that will deny New England residents in GISC, Tenterfield and Uralla Shire Councils of an important rail link with Wallangarra and the rest of QLD further north?
- Are there not other tourist destinations within the ARC, TSC or GISC local government areas (LGA) where a cycling/walking trail can be built, without destroying a publicly owned valuable transport asset?
- .Why are estimated visitor numbers not already published by ARC of people who probably ride on the many thousands of kilometres of existing cycling/walking trails throughout the Northern Tablelands?
- Why is it that ARC does not give equal consideration to the plan proposed by New England Regional Railway Inc (NERi) and Northern Regional Railway Company (NRRC) to run trains from Armidale to Ben Lomond? They have applied via for a license via UGL Regional Linx to the NSW Government already for this to happen.
- Shouldn’t the 3 ARC councillors, who are members of Friends of NERT, distance themselves from ARC decisions to do with the cycling/walking trail in the GNR easement, instead of supporting, especially with precious financial resources ARC ratepayers? By now ARC has allocated more than $2 million to engage the NSW Public Works as consultants and prepare reports. They have already called for tenders to demolish the GNR rail infrastructure, even before the NSW Govt has approved their cycling/walking trail.
Talk about putting the cart before the horse.
Are there not other projects in ARC local governement area (LGA) area that should receive attention compared to a non-essential recreational project like the cycling/walking trail? For example:
Delivering a potable water supply to all residents in the LGA, especially around Guyra,
- Reducing the vast number of road pot holes that ARC has a primary legal responsibility to maintain
- In the past ARC was not able to secure full funding for cycling/walking trail and meet the timeline set by the funding agency. In the ARC’s case $5.4m and in GISC’s case $9+ million of grabt funbding was withdrawn. Both councils have not secured full funding yet. What guarantee is there they will succeed this time?
Despite repeated requests to Armidale’s Mayor Sam Coupland and the other councillors to investigate the off-formation cycling/walking trail design option, why are ARC reluctant to do so?
The proper way foward to find a common ground solution, is by calling a round table discussion among all stakeholders in the Armidale LGA;
- who want to retain the GNR rail infrastructure, which are critical for the creation of news jobs by NEID and Natural Paths on the site of the former Guyra meatworks,
- NEID and Natural Paths have already applied to use the rail siding into their land parcel and the GNR line, via Armidale to the Qube Intermodal Hub at Tamworth.
Supporting one community group – Friends of NERT, which appears to be made up of a majority of people who do not even live in the Armidale LGA, and ignoring other community groups of residents and ratepayers, who have a different vision for the GNR easement for future passenger, freight and historic train activity in the short term, reflects pressure from some powerful vested economic and political interests!
Several Councillors, including the Mayor, have never declared their membership of FoNERT when issues have been discussed and voted on. Is this not a breach of governance rules?
It is a divisive, selfish and undemocratic process that has no possibility of reaching the best possible solution.
ARC has to accept full responsibility dor the angry division between the residents and ratepayers of the Armidale LGA!
United we can win like those in Orange who got a second train to Sydney from this city centric NSW Labor government.
Not a question if a rail trail can be beneficial?
It is a question as to whether we should ignore rail proposals for the same region that can even more beneficial in terms of tourism, mobility and connectivity. Residents and rate payers of the Armidale LGA do not have to choose between the two. We can have both, if ARC and FoNERT modify their current design to plave the cycling/walking trail off-foirmation, beside the existing GNR line.
But one has to ask does ARC have a genuine desire to find a solution for long term benefit of the majority of fresidents in the northern half of the federal electorate of New England.
Dr Siri Gamage
Armidale Rail Transport Advocate
4-nov-2026
